Written by Brody Rupert (Contributor to SharmSports)

We have officially reached the NFL offseason, and it is time for teams to start thinking about the draft in April.

The Tennessee Titans earned the number 4 pick, enabling them to grab a premier player to help them for the future. They could also potentially trade back and acquire more draft capital to fill their holes. Let’s dive into some potential selections for the first round centered around pick 4.

No. 1: EDGE Reuben Bain Jr., Miami

One of the most pressing needs for the Titans is at the edge rusher position. Outside of Jeffery Simmons, the team has very little going for it in terms of pass rush, and Bain would help fill the hole.

The 6’3, 275-pound junior posted 9.5 sacks in the 2025 season, but numbers do not do his impact justice. He was constantly in the backfield creating pressures, leading the country in hurries with 54.

Bain, while a bit untraditional for the edge position, being stocky, slower, and having short arms, is a force to be reckoned with. He earned himself the ACC Defensive Player Of The Year as well as being a consensus All-American due to his great 2025 campaign.

At this point in time, Bain seems like the favorite to be the Titans’ pick at number 4 if he is available. Back-to-back top 5 picks from the University of Miami might be in the cards.

No. 2: LB Arvell Reese, Ohio State

Arvell Reese is an interesting one – it is unclear if he will be used as an edge rusher or an off-ball linebacker. The 6’4, 243-pound junior put up 6.5 sacks and 69 total tackles in 2025, and is expected to be a top 5 pick.

The upside of Arvell Reese as an edge rusher is his elite speed for his size. This does not take away from his strength and ability to shed an offensive lineman or fight his way inside to stuff a run.

His versatility may be a great thing for Robert Saleh’s defense, as he can drop back into coverage when the team simulates pressure, often involving an edge rusher dropping back while Mike and Will linebackers rush.

Reese is not a clear-cut prospect, but he is certainly a player who can wreck a game and really improve the Titans' defensive line. He is certainly a name to watch out for in April.

No. 3: EDGE David Bailey, Texas Tech

If the Titans want someone with proven sack production, David Bailey is just the guy. The 6’3, 250-pound senior posted 14.5 sacks in 2025 and dominated many of the top offensive tackles in the country.

Where Bailey shines is his speed off the edge. His 4.52 speed mixed with high acceleration and agility makes him difficult to stop for offensive tackles, especially if they can’t match his athleticism.

Bailey’s biggest weakness is his size and strength. He is slightly undersized for a full-time edge rusher and is not strong enough to get through some tackles.

He is not as great at run defense as push rush, which is attributed to his strength to fight through blocks.

Overall, David Bailey may be the most proven edge rushing prospect in this NFL draft and has the ability to set the edge and be a game wrecker in the NFL.

No. 4: WR Carnell Tate, Ohio State

The other biggest need for the Tennessee Titans is at the wide receiver position. Cam Ward will be going into his second season and needs some help. A true number one receiver may be the best way to instantly elevate this offense.

Carnell Tate shines as a route runner. Despite not having elite speed, he is able to create separation and make big plays. His 6”2 frame allows him to make physical catches, while his crisp route running and large strides help him get by defenders for long touchdowns.

He hauled in 48 catches for 838 yards and 9 touchdowns in only 10 games in 2025, while averaging an impressive 17.5 yards per catch.

He is versatile and able to line up as both an X and Z, and is potentially the best deep threat in the draft. The ability to stretch the field is something the Titans need, and Tate would fill that well.

No. 5: WR Jordyn Tyson, Arizona State

Jordyn Tyson: not the fastest or the biggest, but technically sound. The 6”2 Junior shines in his route running and versatility. He can make sharp cuts and bursts of speed to find open space in his routes.

He commonly lines up both outside the numbers and in the slot, putting up 1100 yards in 2024 and 711 in 2025, while totalling 22 touchdowns in his three years playing in college.

Tyson, while not being the largest wide receiver, is able to make contested catches and physical jump balls. He would be Cam Ward’s best friend.

He is also a good run blocker, which is something that will impress scouts and coaches. A run blocking receiver is invaluable for screen passes and run-pass options to improve an offense’s versatility

His physical metrics may not be overly impressive, but don’t be mistaken, Tyson is potentially the most skilled wide receiver in this draft class and has a high upside as a number 1 receiver.

WR Makai Lemon, USC

If the Titans want someone coming off a stellar final season in college, Makai Lemon may be the choice. His 1156 yards and 11 touchdowns were enough to earn him the Biletnikoff award, given to the nation’s top wide receiver.

Lemon shines in the slot and does his best work after the ball is in his hand. He has great spatial awareness, and speed makes him dangerous.

While he has a low catch radius because of his shorter wingspan and size, he has great hands. He can strip the ball out of the air and make impressive catches over corners.

He is also a great route runner who makes moves to find open space to catch the football, where he will then fight for every inch he can get.

While pick 4 may be a bit high for the junior, Lemon is a strong first-round prospect that will be there if the team chooses to trade back for draft capital.

RB Jeremiyah Love, Notre Dame

Now, running back isn’t the position the Titans need to prioritize, but they could jump on the opportunity to get the clear cut rb1 in this draft class to be a game changer on offense.

Jeremiyah Love is coming off back-to-back 1,000-yard seasons in college and just put up over 1300 yards and 18 touchdowns in 2025, which was enough to earn him the Doak Walker award for the nation's top running back.

It is hard to find a flaw in Love’s game – he has top-end speed, extreme agility, and can explode for huge gains. He is patient behind his offensive line and absorbs contact to fight for extra yards.

He is also great at receiving out of the backfield, being a good route runner with reliable hands. After he catches the ball, he can make men miss in the open field for big gains.

The only potential downside is his size, paired with his ability to be a 3-down back. Many believe that because he is smaller, it will be harder for him to stay on the field.

Love is potentially the most put-together prospect in this draft. He can start right away and immediately make an impact on the offense.

Safety Caleb Downs, Ohio State

The final player that could potentially be picked at 4 is one that could be labelled as ”generational” for his position. Caleb Downs is potentially the best prospect at safety in many years.

The 6”0, 205-pound junior is a stud, plain and simple. He plays like a linebacker and puts his full effort into each and every play.

He lined up all over the field for Ohio State, getting reps at linebacker, strong safety, free safety, and even occasionally being on the edge. He shines all over and has incredible instincts for a defender.

He is a massive hitter and a ball hawk, causing game-changing plays at any instant. He can lift a defense to new levels by shutting down half the field like it is nothing.

I don’t think the Titans will pick him, but it would certainly mean locking the safety position down for a long time with a stud.

2026 Titans Draft Board: Version 1